Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Harrison Searles's avatar

Professor Koyoma,

You connect the pursuit of “a stronger and more effective state apparatus” with “ever more general statements of the rule of law.” You acknowledge Frederick II’s arbitrary conduct, but I would like to understand more precisely how the strengthening of royal administration translated into restraints on his intervention in judicial decisions. The Arnold affair of 1779–80 makes that question concrete.

Christian Arnold, the hereditary tenant of a watermill in the Neumark, fell behind on his rent. He attributed his difficulties to a neighboring landowner’s fishpond, which he alleged deprived his mill of water. His landlord obtained a judgment for the arrears, and the mill was subsequentrly sold at auction. After repeated adverse rulings, Arnold successfully sought redress from Frederick II.

Frederick dispatched Colonel von Heucking to investigate. Heucking’s report supported the millers’ complaint, but the Kammergericht—the royal high court in Berlin—upheld the earlier decisions against them. Frederick rejected that conclusion, dismissed Grand Chancellor von Fürst, and had judicial officials arrested. Writing to his justice minister, Zedlitz, he declared:

“I give more belief to an honest Officer, who has honor in the heart of him, than to all your Advocates and sentences.” < https://www.digitale-sammlungen.de/en/view/bsb11236309?page=527,528>

When Zedlitz refused to pronounce the condemnation Frederick demanded, the king imposed the sentence himself. What more, he imposed punishments on judges, On 1 January 1780, he ordered six judicial officials dismissed, sentenced to a year’s fortress imprisonment, and required to compensate the Arnolds from their own resources. < https://www.digitale-sammlungen.de/en/view/bsb11236309?page=529,530> To the best of my knowledge, they were subsequently confined at Spandau and released in September, before completing their full term.

I must therefore ask: Does Frederick’s preference for an officer’s honor over judicial reasoning (what one might even call "the rule of law") therefore not suggest that social identity continued to shape whose judgment he trusted? It suggests that actual history is much more messy than your images of “Identity Rules” and “General Rules” above suggest, to the point of being unrecognizable. To me, the Arnold affair demonstrated that, for good and for ill, Frederick II was more than willing to take the law into his own hands when he believed conventional rules were unjust.

Ready for more?