7 Comments
User's avatar
Tim Starr's avatar

You keep making different arguments than the ones you say you're making. You haven't refuted the propositions that Prussia was absolutist or an example of state-led industrialization at all. You've merely found that Prussian Absolutism approximated the rule of law (but only for a while), and that Prussia's state-led industrialization wasn't deserving of that much credit for Prussia's economic success. Both are true, but what you claimed is that Prussia wasn't absolutist or an example of state-led industrialization, both of which are false. I address this in two essays:

https://freemarketsandfirepower.substack.com/p/dr-jekyll-and-mr-bismarck-the-split

https://freemarketsandfirepower.substack.com/p/how-frederick-the-great-made-the?utm_source=publication-search

E.g., the recovery of production methods from prior to the Thirty Years' War was actually a great improvement for Prussia at the time (even though those production methods were backwards compared to Britain), and the Prussian conquest of Silesia from Austria was done to capture strategic economic production for Prussia, which had developed because Austria had greater separation of Church and State than Prussia, which allowed for greater economic freedom.

Mark Koyama's avatar

I didn't know your essays on the topic so will check them out. That said I think you're talking past/misreading the purpose of these essays. Whether I have "refuted the propositions that Prussia was absolutist or an example of state-led industrialization" depends on the working definitions of absolutism and state-led industrialization we agree to work with. With regards to the latter, I can absolutely agree the state played a role in the economic recovery from the Seven Years War but still say that Prussia doesn't offer a example of state-led industrialization where the term industrialization refers to a structural transformation of the economy (along the lines that happen in Germany after 1850).

Mark's avatar

Prussian state send the first steam engine to my hometown. No one had any real use of it. For a while it pumped water.

Years later some young entrepreneur opened a first small textile factory. And seeing its success the rich textile traders in town got together and founded what was to become the biggest linen weaving factory on the continent. In sum: it was indeed very helpful that the Prussian state did not object to industrialisation. ;)

Mark's avatar

Prussian state send the first steam engine to my hometown. No one had any real use of it. For a while it pumped water.

Years later some young entrepreneur opened a first small textile factory. And seeing its success the rich textile traders in town got together and founded what was to become the biggest linen weaving factory on the continent. In sum: it was indeed very helpful that the Prussian state did not object to industrialisation. ;)

Mark's avatar

Prussian state send the first steam engine to my hometown. No one had any real use of it. For a while it pumped water.

Years later some young entrepreneur opened a first small textile factory. And seeing its success the rich textile traders in town got together and founded what was to become the biggest linen weaving factory on the continent. In sum: it was indeed very helpful that the Prussian state did not object to industrialisation. ;)

Mark's avatar

Prussian state send the first steam engine to my hometown. No one had any real use of it. For a while it pumped water.

Years later some young entrepreneur opened a first small textile factory. And seeing its success the rich textile traders in town got together and founded what was to become the biggest linen weaving factory on the continent. In sum: it was indeed very helpful that the Prussian state did not object to industrialisation. ;)

Tim Starr's avatar

Yes, it depends on the definitions, and you didn’t provide yours. I’m using the standard ones. Prussia was the most Absolutist part of Europe after Russia - manorialist/seignoralist, with no separation of church & state, and serfdom until its abolition from above after the Napoleonic Wars. Neither the King in Prussia, the Chancellor, nor the Kaiser after unification were popularly-elected, only the legislature, which had no command authority over the military nor any say in foreign policy. At its best, Prussian Despotism was benign, but it was still despotic.

Figuring out how the Prussian/German economy changed is good, but it also stayed the same in ways that led to WWI & WWII, and that needs to be included, too. If Absolutism and state-led, military-led industrialization had really been abandoned, then those wars wouldn’t have happened.