12 Comments
User's avatar
Javier Gomez's avatar

they key is state capacity. the anglo saxons didnt necessarily have high gpd per capita compared to other north european regions, but they ran a centralized state with the capacity os raising large sums of silver, a system developed during the viking invasions to pay for things like danegeld. this is what the normans and others saw in the english state, not high gdp but a centralized system from which to extract rents.

Michael Magoon's avatar

I agree.

I am very skeptical of the claim that Anglo-Saxon England was significantly wealthier per capita than other Eurasian societies. I think that it took centuries for England to achieve that level.

Anatoly Karlin's avatar

Worth noting Alfred the Great (late 9C) was unusually precocious in urging English elites, including his own family, to acquire vernacular English language literacy. This is probably what enabled the appearance of this unusually capable administrative state in late Anglo-Saxon England.

Peter Defeel's avatar

This is great work. You could send a copy to TRIH, they do have question time sometimes.

However, Tom did say Western Europe. Spain is southern. And the ability for the state to garner taxes matters to invaders looking to be bribed or to stay. So, both right.

Mark Koyama's avatar

yeah, Tom qualified it and tweeted this on X.

James's avatar

Does this conclusion change if we look at English regions? The study above has 'GB' for its GDP estimates, what if we exclude Scotland, Wales, the SW, and North England beyond say York? Seems possible that SE England may have been economically closer to the Netherlands, for example.

Severn Man A's avatar

Wealth at the time was largely dependent on agricultural productivity, so as you sort of allude to it would be a split down the SE/NW or lowland/upland, the Tees-Exe line. Note all the large towns of medieval England (and wider GB) sit to the south or east of this line. London, Winchester, York, Lincoln, Norwich, Bristol, etc.

Towards late pre industrial times (16/17th C) you start to get big coastal/riverine trading towns on the N/W of the line, Newcastle, Glasgow, Liverpool. Over the same period, you also get towns emerging due to centralised government action (Edinburgh as the Scottish capital, Plymouth as a naval and ship manufacturing centre). Note these are all on or near the coast, inland urban centers on the NW side only emerge in industrial times proper.

Mark Koyama's avatar

The estimate is actually based on England as data for Scotland/Wales for that period doesn’t exist.

Stephen Day's avatar

Great post, I shared it with my family.

The argument that England was wealthy compared to its war-torn neighbors is convincing, but not very impressive! It was a low bar.

Etymon's avatar

London with perhaps 10,000–25,000 inhabitants and York around 10,000 on the eve of the Norman Conquest. There’s something lovely about imagining the history of English on that human scale, the voices in the streets and markets, and the words changing hands alongside the goods. Fascinating read.

David Wilson's avatar

Economists are so dumb. Key idiocy is your insistence that an urban population of 10% can't deliver ecnomic growth. It did throughout meidiaeval period.Next your reliance on Malthusian ideas. Read Alan Macfarlane (Cambridge) who. Knows more about this than anyone. Something was going on in England from an early period. There were no peasants for a start. Catch up quickly with his The Culture of Capitalism, and read on...

Mark Koyama's avatar

Interesting that you think that I haven't read Alan Macfarlane . . . not sure about the relevance of anything else though.