Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim Starr's avatar

You keep making different arguments than the ones you say you're making. You haven't refuted the propositions that Prussia was absolutist or an example of state-led industrialization at all. You've merely found that Prussian Absolutism approximated the rule of law (but only for a while), and that Prussia's state-led industrialization wasn't deserving of that much credit for Prussia's economic success. Both are true, but what you claimed is that Prussia wasn't absolutist or an example of state-led industrialization, both of which are false. I address this in two essays:

https://freemarketsandfirepower.substack.com/p/dr-jekyll-and-mr-bismarck-the-split

https://freemarketsandfirepower.substack.com/p/how-frederick-the-great-made-the?utm_source=publication-search

E.g., the recovery of production methods from prior to the Thirty Years' War was actually a great improvement for Prussia at the time (even though those production methods were backwards compared to Britain), and the Prussian conquest of Silesia from Austria was done to capture strategic economic production for Prussia, which had developed because Austria had greater separation of Church and State than Prussia, which allowed for greater economic freedom.

Mark's avatar

Prussian state send the first steam engine to my hometown. No one had any real use of it. For a while it pumped water.

Years later some young entrepreneur opened a first small textile factory. And seeing its success the rich textile traders in town got together and founded what was to become the biggest linen weaving factory on the continent. In sum: it was indeed very helpful that the Prussian state did not object to industrialisation. ;)

5 more comments...

Ready for more?